 St. John Fisher | 1 | Sortisio singled to left field. |
| St. John Fisher | 1 | Sortisio stole second. |
| St. John Fisher | 1 | Mazierski walked. |
| St. John Fisher | 1 | Prince struck out swinging. |
| St. John Fisher | 1 | Paeglow hit by pitch; Mazierski advanced to second; Sortisio advanced to third. |
| St. John Fisher | 1 | Kirker to c for Neale. |
| St. John Fisher | 1 | Neale to dp for Kirker. |
| St. John Fisher | 1 | Neale lined into double play ss to 2b; Mazierski out on the play. |
 Saint Joseph’s | 1 | C. Tripp struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 1 | L. Pomerleau walked. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 1 | M. Elliott struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 1 | M. Harrison struck out swinging. |
| St. John Fisher | 2 | Kirker struck out. |
| St. John Fisher | 2 | Ventrone grounded out to 2b. |
| St. John Fisher | 2 | Schermerhorn grounded out to 2b. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | J. Murphy struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | Neale to c. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | Kirker to dp. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | M. Bailey struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 2 | K. Gaddy struck out swinging. |
| St. John Fisher | 3 | Balsano walked. |
| St. John Fisher | 3 | Balsano out at second cf unassisted. |
| St. John Fisher | 3 | Sortisio grounded out to ss. |
| St. John Fisher | 3 | Mazierski singled through the left side. |
| St. John Fisher | 3 | Mazierski stole second. |
| St. John Fisher | 3 | Prince walked. |
| St. John Fisher | 3 | Paeglow popped up to ss. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | D. Pinkham walked. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | K. Chadbourn struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | C. Tripp struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 3 | L. Pomerleau struck out. |
| St. John Fisher | 4 | Kirker to c for Neale. |
| St. John Fisher | 4 | Neale to dp for Kirker. |
| St. John Fisher | 4 | Kirker to dp. |
| St. John Fisher | 4 | Neale to c. |
| St. John Fisher | 4 | Neale hit by pitch. |
| St. John Fisher | 4 | Neale grounded into double play 2b to ss to 1b; Neale out on the play. |
| St. John Fisher | 4 | Ventrone lined out to 2b. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | M. Elliott singled up the middle. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | M. Harrison popped up to 2b. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | M. Elliott advanced to second on a passed ball. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | J. Murphy walked. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | M. Lee pinch ran for J. Murphy. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | M. Bailey struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 4 | K. Gaddy struck out. |
| St. John Fisher | 5 | J. Murphy to c for M. Lee. |
| St. John Fisher | 5 | Schermerhorn grounded out to ss. |
| St. John Fisher | 5 | Balsano struck out swinging. |
| St. John Fisher | 5 | Sortisio popped up to ss. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | D. Pinkham struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | K. Chadbourn struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 5 | C. Tripp out at first p to 2b. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Mazierski singled up the middle. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Mazierski stole second. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Prince grounded out to p; Mazierski advanced to third. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Paeglow reached on a fielder's choice, advanced to second. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Piparo pinch ran for Paeglow. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Kubik to dp for Kirker. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Kubik singled to left field, advanced to second on the throw, RBI; Piparo advanced to third; Mazierski scored. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Neale popped up to ss. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Kubik pinch hit. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Ventrone walked. |
| St. John Fisher | 6 | Schermerhorn reached on a fielder's choice; Ventrone out at second ss unassisted. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 6 | Paeglow to 1b for Piparo. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 6 | L. Pomerleau grounded out to 2b. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 6 | M. Elliott struck out. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 6 | M. Harrison grounded out to 1b unassisted. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Balsano singled to left field. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Balsano stole second. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Sortisio singled, advanced to second on the throw, RBI; Balsano scored. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Mazierski singled up the middle; Sortisio advanced to third. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Mazierski stole second. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Prince walked. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Paeglow flied out to lf, 2 RBI; Prince advanced to third on the throw; Mazierski scored; Sortisio scored. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Kubik singled to right center, RBI; Prince scored. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | K. Smith to p for K. McFadden. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Neale singled, advanced to second on the throw; Kubik advanced to third. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Ventrone reached first on an error by ss, advanced to second; Neale scored, unearned; Kubik scored, unearned. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Schermerhorn singled through the right side; Ventrone advanced to third. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Keane pinch hit for Balsano. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Keane grounded out to 3b; Schermerhorn advanced to second, advanced to third on the throw; Ventrone scored, unearned. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Keib pinch hit for Sortisio. |
| St. John Fisher | 7 | Keib struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 7 | Keib to cf. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 7 | Grosvenor to c for Neale. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 7 | Balsano to 3b for Keane. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 7 | J. Murphy struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 7 | M. Bailey struck out swinging. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 7 | K. Gaddy singled through the left side. |
| Saint Joseph’s | 7 | D. Pinkham struck out swinging. |